West Indies Cricket Fans Forum

Font size: +
4 minutes reading time (875 words)

Support for President Ali on Payara review


There is much support for President Ali in the diaspora on the review of the Payara FDP and for renegotiation of the oil contract.
However, it is very difficult, though not impossible, to break a contract with a multinational corporation (MNC). Breaking a contract is fraught with serious consequences, some of which are geo-political. Anyone who has studied political science would know how MNCs shape domestic politics, and one has to have a balanced relationship with them.
Nevertheless, Government must attempt to seek some kind of additional benefits for Guyana, and certainly enforcement of, as well as variation in, local content agreements. It requires best negotiation skills and strategies to get Exxon to give more benefits to Guyana without actually billing Guyana for them. Guyana is today the most profitable asset Exxon has. It has been dumping various assets around the globe but retaining Guyana’s, which is described as “new frontier”.

In fact, Exxon has been de-listed on the NY Stock Exchange. Guyana is its saving grace for now; the best deal Exxon ever got globally on making money.
The least that President Ali can do is to review Payara and reset it. People must put aside all the bad press and innuendoes and allow the Government to proceed with the completion of the review of the FDP. It is only fair that a new Government be given some leeway over the review and its negotiations with Exxon. Suggestions can be made to reset the agreement.
The Government is looking at the bigger picture, the long-term future of the oil industry, in seeking a review. It will set the model for future reviews of FDPs, and there may be another dozen over the next 30 years, the term of life of oil extraction. Review of Payara gives Government an opportunity to set its own standards based on world recognized best practices on FDP, and the Government will not disappoint.
While Payara FDP is being reviewed as committed, the Government has no choice in the selection of the reviewer. The Canadian donor selects the reviewer, which is led by Ms Allison Redford and comprises Guyanese-Canadians as well.
Payara is a complicated project. I can’t imagine Redford would rubberstamp things; I expect a professional review. Further independent review of the FDP can and should be undertaken by the Government to the satisfaction of critics, in order to maximise benefits to Guyana.
As revealed, Bayphase did the technical review of the Payara FDP for the Granger Administration, and the Redford Team is conducting a review of the FDP. As reported, the Redford Team is reviewing the methodology used in the FDP. When completed, it is hoped that it would be a framework for future negotiation – creating a model that would work for Guyana and perhaps other countries in similar predicament as Guyana.
Contrary to what is rumoured, there is no conflict of interest between the Redford Team and Exxon. It is noted that the lawyers retained by the preceding Government for the Production Sharing Agreement (PSA) and preparation of earlier FDPs were blatantly conflicted with Exxon. They were lobbyists for Exxon; that in and of itself raises legal questions about the contract. The lawyers failed the preceding Guyana Government in oversight role. Its report is due by weekend.
The emphasis on Payara review is not on PSA, but on issues pertaining to the environment and role of local stakeholders in supplying materials and resources and providing service to Exxon. So far, under the previous regime, Guyanese have minimal role in local content, other than supplying bhajji and bora. The last Government did not listen to public views on local content.
The Ali Administration is listening. The PSA concluded by the Granger Administration in 2016 is lopsided in favour of Exxon. The Government had an opportunity to negotiate a fair contract (with higher royalty and profit-sharing), but failed in that mission. We read that it refused sound advice, and that the negotiator, Minister Trotman, was instructed to sign the contract. Who instructed him to sign the contract we don’t know, and he won’t reveal the name/names.
Was the Exxon contract negotiated in good faith? Did the Government send a competent team to do the negotiation? Was independent technical advice proffered? Trotman should not have negotiated and/or signed the contract, unless it was reviewed by experts acting on behalf of the interests of the nation. He said he didn’t read it; he should have. One cannot enter into a contract without reading it. Why wasn’t it read?
It was irresponsible behaviour not to have read the contract, he was acting in the nation’s interest. Was he forced to sign it? And if so, by whom? Somebody or some bodies, not the Ali Administration, must be held accountable for this PSA and the conflict of interest associated with it. The Ali Government has to honour the contract, unless it can legally be shown to be unfair and Exxon was at fault. One has to make a strong, legal case for renegotiation. The Exxon contract was negotiated and signed in the US, so an American court has jurisdiction.
President Ali has acted wisely to recover an unjust situation on oil development. He deserves support for his present course of action.

Stay Informed

When you subscribe to the blog, we will send you an e-mail when there are new updates on the site so you wouldn't miss them.

Paediatrician Dr Seepersaud Chatterdeo passes away
ExxonMobil is talking from a position of declining...

Related Posts


Guyana Diaspora Forum

We have a large database of Guyanese worldwide.  Most of our readers are in the USA, Canada, and the UK.  Our Blog and Newsletter  would not only carry  articles and videos on Guyana, but also other articles on a wide range of subjects that may be of interest to our readers in over 200 countries, many of them non-Guyanese  We hope that you like our selections.

It is estimated that over one million Guyanese, when counting their dependents, live outside of Guyana.  This exceeds the population of Guyana, which is now about 750,000.  Many left early in the 50’s and 60’s while others went with the next wave in the 70’s and 80’s.  The latest wave left over the last 20 years. This outflow of Guyanese, therefore, covers some three generations. This outflow still continues today, where over 80 % of U.G. graduates now leave after graduating.  We hope this changes, and soon.

Guyanese, like most others, try to keep their culture and pass it on to their children and grandchildren.  The problem has been that many Guyanese have not looked back, or if they did it was only fleetingly.  This means that the younger generations and those who left at an early age know very little about Guyana since many have not visited the country.  Also, if they do get information about Guyana, it is usually negative and thus the cycle of non-interest is cultivated.

This Guyana Diaspora Online Forum , along with its monthly newsletter, aims at bringing Guyanese together to support positive news, increase travel and tourism in Guyana and, in general, foster the birth of a new Guyana, which has already begun notwithstanding the negative news that grabs the headlines.  As the editor and manager of the publication, I am committed to delivering Blog entries and Newsletters that are politically balanced, and focused on the positive ideas we wish to share and foster among Guyanese.

SawyerWeather could force changes in XIs as Australia look to level terms with India(25.11.2023, 12:36)(12:36)0
AlondraSunil Gavaskar was a big fan of Rohan Kanhai
Sunil fell in love with
This extraordinary shot in cricket by the great Rohan kanhai which stayed in Gavaskars memory !!!!
(25.11.2023, 08:41)(08:41)0
ketchimAustralia WIN WC 2023 ~(20.11.2023, 13:37)(13:37)0
ketchimIndia vs Australia FINAL(16.11.2023, 14:01)(14:01)0
ketchimAustralia davances to Final after win over Proteas 1(16.11.2023, 14:01)(14:01)0
AllenIndia advances to Final via Win over Kiwis ~(15.11.2023, 13:05)(13:05)0
AlondraSunil Narine has called time on his eight-year international career. He last played for West Indies in a T20I in August 2019.

"I appreciate it has been over four years since I last played for West Indies, but today I am announcing my retirement from international cricket," Narine wrote on Instagram.
(05.11.2023, 13:43)(13:43)0
RaelynSouth Africa sell out and fold for 83 vs guess who ? LOL(05.11.2023, 12:56)(12:56)0
ketchimPakistan Win D/L method chasing Kiwis mammoth score of 401 : unbelieveable !!(04.11.2023, 10:41)(10:41)0
ketchimSrell Out Lanka 14 -6 !(02.11.2023, 09:25)(09:25)0
YaritzaIt will be a SA vs India final WC!(02.11.2023, 06:09)(06:09)0
ketchimProteas whack Kiwis by 190 runs!(01.11.2023, 13:07)(13:07)0
ketchimAfghanistan need 9 runs in 34 balls(30.10.2023, 11:20)(11:20)0
ketchimGuyana beat Barbados !(30.10.2023, 10:10)(10:10)0
ketchimIndia thump England by 100 runs !(29.10.2023, 11:00)(11:00)0
ketchim1. 771 runs scored !(28.10.2023, 10:54)(10:54)0
ketchimRecords GALORE Oz vs. Kiwis WC 2023(28.10.2023, 10:53)(10:53)0
ketchimEngland walloped by Lanka !(26.10.2023, 11:04)(11:04)0
ketchimMaxwell 40 ball TON !(25.10.2023, 16:05)(16:05)0
ketchimAustralia beat Netherlands by 309 runs lol(25.10.2023, 11:25)(11:25)0
AnnaleeNext month is barrel ? season.
Don't mek problem with yuh family overseas ??.
(22.10.2023, 18:20)(18:20)0
ketchimGuyana vs. Trinidad Super 50 !(21.10.2023, 12:13)(12:13)0
ketchimEngland thumped by South Africa : WC(21.10.2023, 11:55)(11:55)0
ketchimBarbados Lost to Jamaica(21.10.2023, 11:54)(11:54)0
ketchimGuyana beat Windwards Super 50 Cup(18.10.2023, 16:45)(16:45)0
NathanNetherlands beat Saffies by 38 runs...(17.10.2023, 13:16)(13:16)0
resodo3152You can get it right away by going to akamsyourpc.com. This link will take you to Microsoft's official website, where you can download it without problems.(15.10.2023, 23:32)(23:32)0
ClydeWhat a momentous occasion for Afghanistan as AfghanAtalan have defeated England, the reigning champions, to register a historic victory. A significant achievement for Afghanistan!(15.10.2023, 18:26)(18:26)0
ketchimSunday Guyana pledges support !(15.10.2023, 11:28)(11:28)0
YareliHappy Saturday(14.10.2023, 11:10)(11:10)0
ArjunFriday the 13th !(13.10.2023, 17:14)(17:14)0
ketchimCanada Thanks giving Today !!(08.10.2023, 10:41)(10:41)0
ketchimthere used to be Less back inaugural 1975 : IT also used to be 60 overs ~(05.10.2023, 16:08)(16:08)0
YareliWhats the point in calling it "WORLD CUP" if there are only 10 teams participating?
(05.10.2023, 14:25)(14:25)0
Tim SandbergWest Indians are the powerhouse for sure(05.10.2023, 01:38)(01:38)0
Tim SandbergThis world cup would not be exciting anymore without West Indies.(05.10.2023, 01:37)(01:37)0
ketchimToronto Blue Jays best of 5 series begins Tonight vs. Minnesota Twins ~(03.10.2023, 13:23)(13:23)0
AbrahamBREAKING: The Portland Trail Blazers are trading guard Jrue Holiday to the Boston Celtics, sources tell ESPN.(01.10.2023, 18:26)(18:26)0
AbrahamI keep looking at this ODI World Cup and thanking God I don't have to watch West Indies take licks, win two games (at most) and come back home in disgrace.(30.09.2023, 17:17)(17:17)0
ketchimGuyana COUNTY cricket Live!(30.09.2023, 11:47)(11:47)0
AbrahamIndia fans, do you want Ravichandran Ashwin in the World Cup squad?(26.09.2023, 15:55)(15:55)0
AbrahamRussian drone strikes on Odesa region(26.09.2023, 15:50)(15:50)0
AbrahamSouth Korea showcases missiles, drones and tanks in rare military parade(26.09.2023, 05:33)(05:33)0
AbrahamPresident Dr Kishore Shallow congratulates Guyana Amazon Warriors on being CPL Champions(25.09.2023, 19:27)(19:27)0
AbrahamFirst thing first big congrats to the Guyana Amazon Warriors and their long suffering fans.

Second thing second only 4 out of 34 CPL games went into the final over this year.

I'm not here to be a cheerleader I'm here to talk the inconvenient truth.

Quality was LOW
(25.09.2023, 19:16)(19:16)0
Yareli62 for 6(24.09.2023, 19:07)(19:07)0
ketchimGoooo Amazon !(24.09.2023, 13:29)(13:29)0
ketchimAmazon Warriors vs Knight Riders !(24.09.2023, 13:22)(13:22)0
ketchimCPL FINAL 7 pm, tonight !(24.09.2023, 13:22)(13:22)0
YareliPresident Irfaan Ali and Guyana Amazon Warriors captain Imran Tahir joined other worshippers at Friday prayers at the Queenstown Masjid.

The Warriors are down to play defending champions Jamaica Tallawahs in Qualifier Two on Friday night from 19:00h at the National Stadium, Providence.

The winner will face four-time champions Trinbago Knight Riders in Sunday's final at the same venue, from 19:00h.

(Photo: Shaz Ally)
(22.09.2023, 19:16)(19:16)0
Go to top