West Indies Cricket Fans Forum

Font size: +

Coalition politics and PNCR power struggle

THE sudden resignation of Simona Broomes from the PNCR party because of what she claims to be the absence of “systems, and consultation” within the party, came at a testing time for the new PNCR leadership. This resignation would not help to alleviate the power struggle within the PNCR for control of the party’s apparatus. Mr Aubrey Norton was elected the new leader of the PNCR to replace former President Mr David Granger and he wants to replace Mr Joseph Harmon as Leader of the Opposition in Parliament. But Mr Harmon, invoking constitutional principles, would not give up his position as Leader of the Opposition, and his recalcitrance is subtly supported by AFC Leader, Mr Khemraj Ramjattan.

This is an untenable situation where a Leader of the Opposition is not a member of the PNCR’s Executive, and he would therefore not necessarily have access to executive decisions (unless Mr Harmon is co-opted to the executive), and this ugly situation could undermine the PNCR’s drive for responsive and responsible governance. Mr Norton has inherited a problem that he did not create. It is perplexing that a leader of a major political party, for example, has no real power over his party’s deliberations in Parliament. The PNCR has entangled itself in a web that they have spun. The existing leadership crisis is a victim of coalition politics!

Mr Harmon says that he was elected by Opposition MPs to the position of Leader of the Opposition for the duration of the 12th Parliament, and further states that he is satisfied with his stewardship as well as with the performance of Opposition MPs. There are rules and procedures in place to remove members of Parliament. For example, the Opposition MPs could, through a vote of no confidence, remove Mr Harmon from that leadership position. Alternatively, Mr Harmon could be recalled by the Representative of the List, Mr David Granger.

As the Opposition Leader who was elected by APNU+AFC MPs, any attempt to remove Mr Harmon therefore must be made by the APNU+AFFC executive and not by the PNCR. The inter-relationships among the PNCR, AFC and smaller parties that constitute the APNU+AFC coalition are governed by the protocols of the Cummingsburg Accord (with subsequent modifications). And the Leader of the APNU+AFC coalition is Mr David Granger, while the General-Secretary is Mr Joe Harmon. It is therefore the APNU+AFC executive that must determine if Mr Harmon should step down as Opposition Leader and not the PNCR executive. This situation is very tricky.

There are indications that if Mr Norton becomes Opposition Leader as well as the Representative of the APNU+AFC List, that he may recall a few AFC MPs because he is not happy that Mr Granger allocated eight parliamentary seats to the AFC when their numerical voting strength at the 2020 polls plummeted to the equivalent of one seat. In making those AFC appointments to Parliament, Mr Granger has simultaneously ignored several PNCR members, like Mr Aubrey Norton, Mr James Bond, Ms Volda Lawrence, Mr Basil Williams, Ms Simona Broomes, Mr Ronald Bulkan and others for that position. They all played significant roles in the 2020 elections.

The AFC does not feel secure that Mr Norton would honour the arrangements (Cummingsburg Accord) made between the smaller parties and Mr Granger’s APNU. They fear that under pressure from the new PNCR executive, Mr Norton would try to remove a few AFC MPs. For this reason, the AFC Leader Mr Khemraj Ramjattan says that any decision cannot be unilateral as there are legal and constitutional constraints involved in any move to replace Mr Harmon with Mr Norton. Mr Ramjattan states that he is not taking sides, but is just guided by the law and the Constitution in this matter. He insists that any approval to replace Mr Harmon must be given by the APNU+AFC body and not by the PNCR executive.

If approval is given by the APNU+AFC, then certain conditions are likely to be set in motion. The AFC will ensure that their MPs are protected; that the Cummingsburg Accord arrangements are observed; and that Mr Harmon gets a face-saving path out. There are strong feelings among many coalition members and supporters that while Mr Harmon’s leadership as Minister in the Office of the Presidency has not been inspiring, he had nevertheless worked assiduously, particularly during the five-month post-election fiasco, to hold onto power tenaciously; not to mention his huge fund-raising efforts for the party. The party should not throw him to the kerb.

Another amazing point relates to the Representative of the APNU+AFC List. Mr Granger, although he is not part of the PNCR executive, is the Representative of the APNU+AFC List and Mr Ramjattan is the Deputy. If Mr Granger steps aside, then it logically follows that Mr Ramjattan takes this position, unless he agrees to make way for Mr Norton. In that case, Mr Norton must get the blessings of the APNU+AFC coalition. But there is another constitutional issue. The Representative and Deputy are designated before an election and whether a replacement could happen after an election is not clear from RoPA. There is no clear succession plan for Representative of the List, apart from clinging to convention that the Representative should be replaced by the Deputy. Also related is this: “who will be the opposition chief scrutineer to replace Amna Ally?” Under the present arrangement, that person should be nominated by the APNU+AFC executive, or by the Leader or Deputy Leader of the List, and not by the PNCR Leader.

The ultimate challenge for the PNCR leadership is to provide Mr Joseph Harmon with a face-saving exit strategy.

Shuman does not understand the doctrine of the sep...
APNU MPs “blinded” by their anti-national stance

Guyana Diaspora Forum

We have a large database of Guyanese worldwide.  Most of our readers are in the USA, Canada, and the UK.  Our Blog and Newsletter  would not only carry  articles and videos on Guyana, but also other articles on a wide range of subjects that may be of interest to our readers in over 200 countries, many of them non-Guyanese  We hope that you like our selections.

It is estimated that over one million Guyanese, when counting their dependents, live outside of Guyana.  This exceeds the population of Guyana, which is now about 750,000.  Many left early in the 50’s and 60’s while others went with the next wave in the 70’s and 80’s.  The latest wave left over the last 20 years. This outflow of Guyanese, therefore, covers some three generations. This outflow still continues today, where over 80 % of U.G. graduates now leave after graduating.  We hope this changes, and soon.

Guyanese, like most others, try to keep their culture and pass it on to their children and grandchildren.  The problem has been that many Guyanese have not looked back, or if they did it was only fleetingly.  This means that the younger generations and those who left at an early age know very little about Guyana since many have not visited the country.  Also, if they do get information about Guyana, it is usually negative and thus the cycle of non-interest is cultivated.

This Guyana Diaspora Online Forum , along with its monthly newsletter, aims at bringing Guyanese together to support positive news, increase travel and tourism in Guyana and, in general, foster the birth of a new Guyana, which has already begun notwithstanding the negative news that grabs the headlines.  As the editor and manager of the publication, I am committed to delivering Blog entries and Newsletters that are politically balanced, and focused on the positive ideas we wish to share and foster among Guyanese.

chNo surprise here: Joe Flacco will be the QB2 again this week, per Saleh. Zach Wilson will be inactive again(02.12.2022, 12:39)(12:39)0
ketchimEngland arrived in Pakistan for the first time in 17 years(28.11.2022, 12:57)(12:57)0
ketchimhttps://www.cricketwindies.com/forum/the-pitch/46544-from-majid-khan-to-waqar-younis(28.11.2022, 12:56)(12:56)0
chPakistan fans - who makes your XI for the first Test against England?(28.11.2022, 12:43)(12:43)0
ketchimDavid Murray 1950 - 2022 Gloveman Rest in peace ~(26.11.2022, 10:41)(10:41)0
RayCristiano Ronaldo to leave Man Utd with immediate effect(22.11.2022, 13:41)(13:41)0
chThere were 56K tickets sold in less than 48 hours to Sunday’s Cleveland-Buffalo game in Detroit — mostly, of course, to Bills’ fans.(19.11.2022, 17:51)(17:51)0
chShould the Toronto Maple Leafs Trade for Rumored Defensemen?(17.11.2022, 13:57)(13:57)0
ketchimBishop pulling a Trini PICONG lol(15.11.2022, 14:40)(14:40)0
RemingtonFormer West Indies fast bowler and current commentator Ian Bishop says all-rounder Hardik Pandya is fit to be the next captain of India’s T20 team.

In the 2022 IPL, Hardik led the Gujarat Titans to their maiden title win in their very first season. Titans led by Pandya won the match against Rajasthan Royal by seven wickets.
(15.11.2022, 13:09)(13:09)0
ketchimShiv presented the MoM and MoS awards !(13.11.2022, 16:01)(16:01)0
ketchimShiv part of presentation party of T20 WC champs England after accepting his Hall of Fame award in Australia !(13.11.2022, 12:34)(12:34)0
ketchimEngland Win WC T20i(13.11.2022, 11:13)(11:13)0
CyrusEngland crucify India to play FINAL T20i versus(10.11.2022, 10:14)(10:14)0
ketchimPakistan thump Kiwis and advances to WC T20iFINAL(09.11.2022, 12:19)(12:19)0
ketchimShiv inducted into Hall of Fame !(08.11.2022, 09:03)(09:03)0
ketchimJinx the chap caught on 94(06.11.2022, 15:27)(15:27)0
ketchimDevon Thomas will clock a Ton as well !(06.11.2022, 15:03)(15:03)0
ketchimDutch Motherland knocks the Dutch Afrikaan outta the T20i World Cup !(06.11.2022, 13:52)(13:52)0
chairmanGood morning(05.11.2022, 08:33)(08:33)0
ketchimCricket Legend Imran Khan shot in leg !(03.11.2022, 10:36)(10:36)0
chairmanShepherd hear what stop bowling, play as a batsman - you can safely make WI team in front Brooks & Rovman. When you settle in you will bowl between overs 7-14.(02.11.2022, 22:24)(22:24)0
ketchimTage need another match before leaving for Australia(02.11.2022, 13:41)(13:41)0
ketchimKacy Carthy 103*(02.11.2022, 13:40)(13:40)0
chSecond successive century for Windward Islands opener Alick Athanaze in Super 50 action today as he reaches his century off 97 balls

Will he get a call up for West Indies in 2023 if this form continues?
(02.11.2022, 12:09)(12:09)0
ZendayaAlick Athanaze 140
Kaveem Hodge 105*

Amari Goodridge 2/57
(02.11.2022, 12:02)(12:02)0
chPowerball jackpot hits $1 billion, its second-highest total ever(01.11.2022, 13:09)(13:09)0
chairmanAllick Alick Athanaze Congratulations on your maiden LIst A Century.(31.10.2022, 17:10)(17:10)0
chairmanOne person called in and said ...dig up all the cricket pitches in the Caribbean and just plant marijuana ??(27.10.2022, 13:59)(13:59)0
chairmanRussian court rejects Griner appeal of her 9-year sentence(25.10.2022, 11:48)(11:48)0
chairmanPhil Simmons has resigned.(24.10.2022, 16:56)(16:56)0
chairmanHappy Diwali(24.10.2022, 16:50)(16:50)0
ketchimHappy DIWALI !(24.10.2022, 14:25)(14:25)0
ketchimSaffies No Result vs Zimbabwe ( neighbours)(24.10.2022, 14:24)(14:24)0
ketchimOooooppps....Bangla?Netherlands !(24.10.2022, 14:23)(14:23)0
JaydenBangladesh thump Ireland ..(24.10.2022, 14:21)(14:21)0
chairmanSri Lanka crush Ireland by nine wickets(24.10.2022, 11:38)(11:38)0
chairmanConsidering the continuous decline in West Indies Cricket over the past two decades.

Do you think Guyana should severed ties from the West Indies Cricket ? Board ?
(22.10.2022, 17:16)(17:16)0
chairmanT20 World Cup: Ireland and Zimbabwe through, West Indies and Scotland out(21.10.2022, 09:50)(09:50)0
ketchimFinal chance for Super 12 OR ~pack up yuh bags and leh we go ~(20.10.2022, 20:57)(20:57)0
ketchimW.I. vs Ireland at Midnight(20.10.2022, 20:56)(20:56)0
VillageBelleAm I missing the obvious???(20.10.2022, 15:09)(15:09)0
VillageBelleHey Krishna.....how do I see the name of person making post on the SB? I have no idea who responded to my posts.(20.10.2022, 15:09)(15:09)0
chairmanCongratulations to Berbice and the other teams that participated in the return of Inter County Cricket to Guyana after many years. Kudos to President Bissoondyal Singh Snr and team.(19.10.2022, 14:23)(14:23)0
chairmanA win is a win(19.10.2022, 14:08)(14:08)0
ketchimWest Indies WIN(19.10.2022, 07:43)(07:43)0
ketchimScotland LOST(19.10.2022, 07:42)(07:42)0
chairmanA win would make Scotland firm favourites to qualify into the Super 12s(18.10.2022, 23:42)(23:42)0
chairmanScotland bat first in Ireland's must-win game(18.10.2022, 23:40)(23:40)0
chairmanNew York city they called it the Concrete Jungle for a reason.(18.10.2022, 13:48)(13:48)0
Go to top