1st ODI: India v West Indies at Kochi, Oct 8, 2014

krishna · 09-23-2014, 09:26 PM · 1 person reading this discussion

#41
We are talking West Indies and a new Chairman of selectors.

I wonder what the view would ahve been had Johnson not been selected who I actually see more as a Test prospect.

Why would you select a man dropped in June for a string of poor performances and after 156 ODIs average a paltry, unacceptable 31!

Why would Lloyd return a confirmed failure in Smith and who after 91 ODIs average 17?

Where do I start with Sammy? He simply is not good enough but T20s yes.

Also what is Holder's role in the squad. He looked very impressive and promising as a 19 year old but seems to have gone backwards with speed, variation, movement etc.

He is capable of batting but what does that mean?

I certainly would have had Blackwood instead of either Johnson, Sammy, Samuels.

I hope they do well and prove me wrong. 



#43
Quote:this is bad work by LLoyd.  I was hoping for the better side to emerge in this selector role from that old soup drinking skunt.  seems like my hope is wasted.


now you believe me when I told you that he was just looking for retirement income???  >Sad

#44
looking at that A team in India : whappen to Fuda ?  :-\

86* , 63 and 47

Mohamed Shami now plays for the XI

#45
Miller and Permaul did extremely well in India ..

#46
[quote author=ketchim link=topic=92903.msg590416#msg590416 date=1411666039]

All Nations are scared of " rocking the boat " for WC 2015 !

England appear to be in a conundrum re a competitive XI ! likewise Australia...
[/quote]

I think this is a poor approach for West Indies to take !

Pybus should "direct " Lloyd to introduce the Youth and have him in the WC squad !

#47
The selection panel of the West Indies Cricket Board announced on Wednesday, a 14-member West Indies A-Team squad for a tour of Sri Lanka, starting next month.

Squad
Carlos Brathwaite (Captain)
Sunil Ambris
Devendra Bishoo
Jermaine Blackwood
Kraigg Brathwaite
Sheldon Cottrell
Miguel Cummins
Kirk Edwards
Andre Fletcher
Assad Fudadin
Shannon Gabriel
Nikita Miller
Shane Shillingford
Chadwick Walton

#48
Braff  made a double century and was MoS vs Bangla and :

got Promoted to the A team  ;D

#49
I would swap Fuda and Nikita : for one of Smith/Simmons/Pollad and Holder

#50
Good thing is they right next door in Sri Lanka  8)

From The Archives

Older threads about similar topics


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)