>

Should cricket introduce red and yellow cards?

More
20 Aug 2014 20:54 #208541 by chairman
Unlike in most other team sports, cricket umpires have no power to eject players from the field of play, with any penalties imposed by officials - such as the International Cricket Council's match referees - after the match.
Introducing football-style red and yellow cards would enable umpires to deal with misdemeanours as and when they occurred, but would be a fundamental change to a sport proud of its gentlemanly traditions.
The concept has been frequently considered by the MCC and was discussed by the ICC earlier this year.

Always tell someone how you feel because opportunities are lost in the blink of an eye but regret can last a lifetime.
cricketwindies.com/forum/

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

  • bala24
  • Visitor
  • Visitor
21 Aug 2014 00:57 #208556 by bala24
Mate, interesting question.Introducing a red card for a player who is not disciplined is fine,but who will you bring in his place..?? 12th man..??
The laws of cricket state: "If there is any breach of the Spirit of the Game by a player failing to comply with the instructions of an umpire, or criticising his decisions by word or action, or showing dissent, or generally behaving in a manner which might bring the game into disrepute, then the umpire concerned shall immediately report the matter to the other umpire. The umpires together shall: (i) inform the player’s captain of the occurrence, instructing the latter to take action. (ii) warn him of the gravity of the offence, and tell him that it will be reported to higher authority (iii) report the occurrence as soon as possible to the Executive of the player’s team and any Governing Body responsible for the match, who shall take such action as is considered appropriate against the captain and player or players, and, if appropriate, the team concerned."

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

  • rayking
  • Visitor
  • Visitor
21 Aug 2014 07:20 #208561 by rayking
That would be quite an interesting addition to cricket, and though we won't see much of a physical confrontation, there are the occasional verbal assaults. If the use of a red card translates to a player leaving the field, then it might change the way subs are used in the game. Probably they may choose a different penalty for each card, maybe it could directly imply percentage of match fees, and subsequent cards depleting it. Looks like the ICC wants to keep it clean.

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

More
21 Aug 2014 11:34 #208625 by timmyj51
Stuff the "red," "yellow", "periwinkle"  or any other cards!  Cricket umps should have the same power as baseball umps: if a
player's verbal abuse goes over the line the umps should be able to give him the heave-ho right on the sport.  Replace him with
12th man, even a 13th or 14th if any more of these "gentlemen players" have to be chucked.    >:(

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

More
21 Aug 2014 14:26 #208676 by docdhruv
Why does cricket have to emulate other sports? Yes there are a few altercations and heated  moments in the game but nothing compared to some of the violence that we see in other sports. Cricket for the most part has been played with exceptional spirit so I dont really think a few bad incidences should cause a fundamental change in our sport.

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

More
21 Aug 2014 19:22 #208734 by timmyj51
Maybe so, but there's been plenty of ugly incidences in the game--Holding kicking down stumps,  Lillee kicking Javed (think that's who it was) and
disgruntled players barging into umps who could do absolutely nothing.  Umps should at least have, as a last resort, the option to chuck out these  [pseudo] "gentlemen."  >:(

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

  • Mail
  • Visitor
  • Visitor
21 Aug 2014 19:49 #208735 by Mail
No.

Umpires need to control matches more effectively and players need to understand where to stop if not bans..... fines mean nothing.

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

More
21 Aug 2014 22:46 #208755 by Kyle
Reminded me of:


Also not really. There's a purpose to cards in football - the other player's act does influence the game directly. Not sure if you can say the same about cricket. Don't know what the big deal is - let them get on with the game, then fine or ban or whatever accordingly by ICC. 

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

More
22 Aug 2014 11:45 #208833 by timmyj51
Sure, let pseudo-gentleman  kick down the stumps and  Jeeves the [lackey] umpire remake them as if nothing's the matter.  Have I got 'em straight? Wanna boot 'em again? >:(

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

  • Mail
  • Visitor
  • Visitor
22 Aug 2014 11:57 #208842 by Mail

That is a significant point.

The only issue with teh ICC is that they apply the rules inconsistently and it was interesting hearing Ian Cappell talk on this subject which supports the West indian perspective.

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

Time to create page: 0.225 seconds
MarissaSteve Smith scored yet another test century today!
The greatest batsman in the world today!
(30.01.2025, 12:21)(12:21)0
MarissaTHE GENUINE WEST INDIES FANS REALLY DID ENJOY AND APPRECIATE THIS VICTORY.(27.01.2025, 06:40)(06:40)0
MarissaAn excellent fight back by the West Indies to dismiss Pakistan for 154. Warrican 4/43 and Motie 3/49. Well done lads. Let the cricket play.(25.01.2025, 10:44)(10:44)0
LanceTrump says he’s considering ‘getting rid of FEMA’ as he visits hurricane-damaged North Carolina(24.01.2025, 18:55)(18:55)0
DeaconCumberbatch(22.01.2025, 11:19)(11:19)0
Marissa$135 fuh reporting yuh mattie to ICE,deez nex few monts going to be quite interesting(22.01.2025, 06:51)(06:51)0
AndersExxonMobil write-down natural gas fields(20.01.2025, 23:42)(23:42)0
MarissaJangoo should be in next game , captain should be dropped,Kacy karty, should be dropped,if roach is fit I would bring him in at the expense of st Clair.(20.01.2025, 16:41)(16:41)0
Baileymessage(20.01.2025, 14:25)(14:25)0
MercyKensington Oval stadium ticket policy(19.01.2025, 23:36)(23:36)0
LanceKraigg’s time is up. He has never truly moved on as a player. Despite being captain and senior batsmen we will lose nothing with investing in a rookie.

He has given his service as an honest and wholehearted performer and would leave with my heartfelt thanks for his contribution.
(18.01.2025, 18:00)(18:00)0
ByronViv richards was the best batsman of
“his era” but he wasn’t better than Brian Lara whether it’s numbers wise or just plain batting talent and skill
Lara is on a level nobody else is on.
(17.01.2025, 17:56)(17:56)0
ByronAmir jangoo replace dasilva(17.01.2025, 06:56)(06:56)0
ByronTevin imlach gets debut(17.01.2025, 06:56)(06:56)0
LindaMy question about the West Indies cricket team.(13.01.2025, 09:06)(09:06)0
ByronWhy doesn't England have big cricket stadiums like those in Australia and India..?(11.01.2025, 15:31)(15:31)0
MaliyahHow do I purchase tickets for the upcoming cricket match at Kensington Oval in Barbados?(11.01.2025, 15:27)(15:27)0
ArielWest Indies vs India T20 match(11.01.2025, 14:59)(14:59)0
LanceFORMER JAMAICA and West Indies left-arm spinner Nikita Miller is excited about imparting his knowledge of the game to the Caribbean side’s spin-bowling unit for the upcoming two-Test series against Pakistan.(10.01.2025, 18:11)(18:11)0
AmosAndrew Strauss steps down as England's director of cricket(10.01.2025, 13:06)(13:06)0
DylanChris Gayle T20 statistics(09.01.2025, 11:11)(11:11)0
SeanHello, I'm excited to join the conversation!(09.01.2025, 04:47)(04:47)0
LanceThe Sydney Cricket Ground (SCG) pitch, used for the recent fifth and final Test of the Border-Gavaskar Trophy (BGT), has received a 'Satisfactory' rating from the International Cricket Council (ICC). The world body has rated all other four BGT venues - Optus Stadium in Perth, Adelaide Oval, the Gabba in Brisbane, and the Melbourne Cricket Ground (MCG) - 'Very Good.'(08.01.2025, 20:03)(20:03)0
LanceYounis Khan to mentor Afghanistan at Champions Trophy 2025(08.01.2025, 20:02)(20:02)0
MercySouth Africa cricket team upcoming matches schedule(07.01.2025, 16:11)(16:11)0
JavierType something here and click Submit or hit Enter...(07.01.2025, 07:37)(07:37)0
IvannaTest comment for registration.(06.01.2025, 16:33)(16:33)0
AdrianDarren Bravo had a remarkable 2020 cricket season, showcasing his skills and talent on the field. His impressive performance was a significant factor in the team's success, and his dedication to the sport is truly admirable. Bravo's ability to adapt to different playing conditions and his consistent batting average made him a valuable asset to the team. What are your thoughts on Darren Bravo's performance in the 2020 cricket season?(06.01.2025, 04:35)(04:35)0
RileyCan you provide me with the contact information for the Czech Cricket Union (Českomoravský Kriketový Svaz)?(06.01.2025, 03:35)(03:35)0
RyleeI am looking for the contact information for the Czech Cricket Union (Českomoravský Kriketový Svaz). Can you please provide it?(05.01.2025, 21:05)(21:05)0
Karsyn2023 West Indies vs England test match series(04.01.2025, 19:29)(19:29)0
ElsaDarren Bravo 2020 cricket season(04.01.2025, 13:21)(13:21)0
Reagan2023 West Indies vs England test match series discussion(04.01.2025, 12:47)(12:47)0
RoyalWest Indies vs England test match series 2023(04.01.2025, 04:45)(04:45)0
LylahWest Indies vs Sri Lanka test series(04.01.2025, 03:06)(03:06)0
LydiaRohan Kanhai(04.01.2025, 01:29)(01:29)0
AryannaWest Indies vs England test match series 2023(04.01.2025, 00:26)(00:26)0
LexieHello, I'm excited to join the Cricket West Indies community!(03.01.2025, 23:05)(23:05)0
MauriceWest Indies vs England test match series 2023(03.01.2025, 16:56)(16:56)0
Kaelyn2023 West Indies vs England test match series(03.01.2025, 16:34)(16:34)0
ScottWest Indies vs England series discussion(03.01.2025, 15:09)(15:09)0
AryannaWest Indies vs England test match series(03.01.2025, 15:08)(15:08)0
Rhettupcoming Test tours(03.01.2025, 13:36)(13:36)0
Mackenzie2023 West Indies vs England test match series(03.01.2025, 10:04)(10:04)0
Lanceindia bowled out cheaply(03.01.2025, 09:45)(09:45)0
GinoWest Indies vs England test match series 2023(03.01.2025, 07:32)(07:32)0
KaidenceJason Holder West Indies captaincy(03.01.2025, 06:43)(06:43)0
AllenWest Indies vs India first test(03.01.2025, 05:35)(05:35)0
MackenzieWest Indies vs England test match series 2023(03.01.2025, 05:24)(05:24)0
KendraWest Indies cricket upcoming Test series(03.01.2025, 03:57)(03:57)0
Kaison
Go to top