>

Sammy: One of WI's many problems

More
19 Nov 2013 11:32 #163680 by chairman
In addition to marking the retirement of India's greatest batsman, the second Test of the 2013 Tendulkar Farewell Series should also have marked the end of Darren Sammy's tenure as West Indies captain. The visitors suffered two humiliating defeats, each in less than three days, and their leader did not exactly recommend himself to the fans by his performance. But his has been such an uneasy reign that losing the crown might have come as some sort of a relief.

The St. Lucian all-rounder has taken fire from all sides, especially from the Caribbean fans who thought him an impostor who was perpetrating a fraud upon West Indies cricket; a player undeserving of a place in the side and one who certainly has no right being captain.

If there is some merit to the substance of some of the criticism, the manner in which it was frequently delivered was mean-spirited - riddled with name-calling and abuse. All of this, of course, is unfair to Sammy. He did not select himself to the position, and no one has ever accused him of giving anything but his best in the service of Caribbean cricket.

Sammy's elevation to the captaincy in October 2010, replacing Chris Gayle, was a reasonable decision by the selectors. At the time it occurred the West Indies authorities had issues with the other likely candidates that needed to be resolved. Three years later, however, it is mystifying that he still occupies the seat.

His character should not really be questioned (though it has been). Smart and seemingly affable, the St. Lucian is a most conscientious member of the team -- a real inspiration to his countrymen and a good example to the youth at a time when boorish behavior is too often associated with our athletes and celebrities.

But Sammy is a good man forced into the wrong line of work. Sammy's tactical awareness, while not being the best, is serviceable. His much larger problem is that he would have struggled to find a place in the side were he not captain. He is neither a potent enough fourth bowler to command a regular spot, nor a skilled enough batsman to bat at six or seven.

Sammy's bowling was never troublesome to begin with, but at least he could shut down an end while more penetrative practitioners operate at the other. Now, if recent outings are anything to go by, he is suffering from a loss of both direction and confidence, evidenced by a reluctance to send down his share of overs.

A very clean striker of the cricket ball, Sammy lacks the technique and temperament to toil through the tough times. His big hitting will occasionally allow him to escape tricky situations; but more often he will perish like he did in the recent Kolkata test, caught by deep-set fielders.

To be fair, West Indies' problem goes far beyond the scant skills of its captain. The real cause of its predicament is its failure to produce enough world-class players to compete with the world's best teams. Big hitting players like Chris Gayle, Marlon Samuels and Kieron Pollard, and the bowling of Sunil Narine made them World T20 champions and formidable opponents in cricket's briefest form, but a general lack of quality means they often fall short of the demands of Test matches.

The last really great batsman to emerge from the Caribbean was Shivnarine Chanderpaul who made his debut in 1994, and the last really great bowler was Curtly Ambrose, who stormed on to the scene in 1988. Compare that reality to those of top Test playing countries like England, India and South Africa.

Consider this list of players who made their Test debut since January 1995: Dale Steyn, Jaques Kallis, Hashim Amla, AB deVilliers, Shaun Pollock from South Africa; Rahul Dravid, VVS Laxman, Virender Sehwag, Harbhajan Singh from India; Kevin Pietersen, James Anderson, Andrew Flintoff, Alastair Cook from England.

The streak of world-beaters that gushed from the Caribbean like cars off an assembly line in the seventies and eighties suddenly came to an end in the nineties, as did their reign of world domination. Since then only rarely have they been worthy challengers to the top teams. This is a predicament the West Indies authorities need to investigate, if they are not already aware of its causes, and take action to fix; otherwise the former kings of cricket are doomed to occupy the lower rungs of the rankings for the foreseeable future.

The throne was snatched away under Richie Richardson's watch in 1995 and none of Courtney Walsh, Brian Lara, Jimmy Adams, Chanderpaul, Jimmy Adams, Carl Hooper, Ramnaresh Sarwan, Gayle or Sammy could reclaim it, as each one, in turn, bore the brunt of the blame for the teams abysmal results.

Yet the main reason for the West Indies' extended poor run has little to do with who is at the helm. No matter how cunning the captain there is not much he can do with a bad team. Even the best tactician in the world still needs players capable of executing whatever plans he may devise.

There is nothing a captain can do during a game to protect batsmen intent on committing suicide, or to improve the technique of those unable to counter the opposition bowling or the prevailing batting conditions. What can he do to impose discipline on bowlers adamant in serving up half-trackers or have difficulty hitting the cut strip? All the great captains: Frank Worrell, Richie Benaud, Clive Lloyd, Mike Brearly, Ian Chappell, Mark Taylor, had one thing in common - they all led good teams.

Darren Sammy does not. Nevertheless a captain should ideally warrant his place in his team. As veteran West Indies journalist, Tony Cozier, writing in the Trinidad Express recently stated: "Any captain is in an impossible position if he cannot command a place in the eleven on cricketing merit; it diminishes his authority."

It is not that Sammy's results are worse than those of his predecessors. Simply, his continued presence disrupts the balance of a side that cannot afford to carry passengers. A more penetrative bowler, or a more capable batsman -- depending on the construct of the team -- would add some logic to the selection process.

The fact that Sammy was reinstated for the coming New Zealand tour means that the selectors, for the time being at least, have resisted the many calls for his head. With the chatter likely to get louder, especially if they are defeated in New Zealand, it is doubtful that Sammy will have their blessings for much longer. After that, however, they will still have a myriad of other problems to tackle.

© Cricbuzz

Always tell someone how you feel because opportunities are lost in the blink of an eye but regret can last a lifetime.
cricketwindies.com/forum/

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

More
19 Nov 2013 11:45 - 23 Nov 2013 21:54 #163685 by Rev Al
The last really great batsman to emerge from the Caribbean was Shivnarine Chanderpaul who made his debut in 1994, and the last really great bowler was Curtly Ambrose, who stormed on to the scene in 1988. Compare that reality to those of top Test playing countries like England, India and South Africa.


https://encrypted-tbn3.gstatic.com/images?q=tbn:ANd9GcSiDwIB3amZe63-VH3kutOWEfLL7ICezccvITcOGIMUbZbTVYHFSA

With West Indies no longer producing quality test batsmen
the great man can play until he is 50----that is excellent news for his devoted fans---who cares if WI cricket remains in the toilet ?

Rev
Last edit: 23 Nov 2013 21:54 by Rev Al.

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

  • zacaroni
  • Visitor
  • Visitor
20 Nov 2013 21:11 #164024 by zacaroni
Many of us do. But you are right about WI cricket being where you say it is. Has been there for a while. How does it get out?

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

More
20 Nov 2013 23:30 #164039 by ketchim
Try a  Plunger  ?  :-\

                     

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

  • zacaroni
  • Visitor
  • Visitor
23 Nov 2013 21:27 #164535 by zacaroni
A plunger pushes stuff down. WI cricket needs lifting up.

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

  • easyrider
  • Visitor
  • Visitor
23 Nov 2013 21:51 #164538 by easyrider
If fundamental problems exist, the face of the team.... the Captain, is not to be blamed. That is symptomatic of a wider concern.

The Captain was placed, and in some cases, he may have been placed by either towing the line which may be just or unjust or he might be there on merit. Public opinion on Sammy is quite universal now.

Replacing Sammy, as he must be soon, will not solve the problems but it is a step in the right direction.

A captain, whatever his shortcomings, did not force anyone to place him and that includes Sammy.

In the case of Sammy there may be the question of integrity and the quality of service and legacy he is providing to his country.

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

  • SpiralArchitect
  • Visitor
  • Visitor
24 Nov 2013 11:15 #164607 by SpiralArchitect
Well, Sammy finally did something today to try and redeem himself. He still has a long way to go but today was as good a batting performance as they come. Great knock which won WI the match

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

Time to create page: 0.171 seconds
AmosAndrew Strauss steps down as England's director of cricket(10.01.2025, 13:06)(13:06)0
DylanChris Gayle T20 statistics(09.01.2025, 11:11)(11:11)0
SeanHello, I'm excited to join the conversation!(09.01.2025, 04:47)(04:47)0
LanceThe Sydney Cricket Ground (SCG) pitch, used for the recent fifth and final Test of the Border-Gavaskar Trophy (BGT), has received a 'Satisfactory' rating from the International Cricket Council (ICC). The world body has rated all other four BGT venues - Optus Stadium in Perth, Adelaide Oval, the Gabba in Brisbane, and the Melbourne Cricket Ground (MCG) - 'Very Good.'(08.01.2025, 20:03)(20:03)0
LanceYounis Khan to mentor Afghanistan at Champions Trophy 2025(08.01.2025, 20:02)(20:02)0
MercySouth Africa cricket team upcoming matches schedule(07.01.2025, 16:11)(16:11)0
JavierType something here and click Submit or hit Enter...(07.01.2025, 07:37)(07:37)0
IvannaTest comment for registration.(06.01.2025, 16:33)(16:33)0
AdrianDarren Bravo had a remarkable 2020 cricket season, showcasing his skills and talent on the field. His impressive performance was a significant factor in the team's success, and his dedication to the sport is truly admirable. Bravo's ability to adapt to different playing conditions and his consistent batting average made him a valuable asset to the team. What are your thoughts on Darren Bravo's performance in the 2020 cricket season?(06.01.2025, 04:35)(04:35)0
RileyCan you provide me with the contact information for the Czech Cricket Union (Českomoravský Kriketový Svaz)?(06.01.2025, 03:35)(03:35)0
RyleeI am looking for the contact information for the Czech Cricket Union (Českomoravský Kriketový Svaz). Can you please provide it?(05.01.2025, 21:05)(21:05)0
Karsyn2023 West Indies vs England test match series(04.01.2025, 19:29)(19:29)0
ElsaDarren Bravo 2020 cricket season(04.01.2025, 13:21)(13:21)0
Reagan2023 West Indies vs England test match series discussion(04.01.2025, 12:47)(12:47)0
RoyalWest Indies vs England test match series 2023(04.01.2025, 04:45)(04:45)0
LylahWest Indies vs Sri Lanka test series(04.01.2025, 03:06)(03:06)0
LydiaRohan Kanhai(04.01.2025, 01:29)(01:29)0
AryannaWest Indies vs England test match series 2023(04.01.2025, 00:26)(00:26)0
LexieHello, I'm excited to join the Cricket West Indies community!(03.01.2025, 23:05)(23:05)0
MauriceWest Indies vs England test match series 2023(03.01.2025, 16:56)(16:56)0
Kaelyn2023 West Indies vs England test match series(03.01.2025, 16:34)(16:34)0
ScottWest Indies vs England series discussion(03.01.2025, 15:09)(15:09)0
AryannaWest Indies vs England test match series(03.01.2025, 15:08)(15:08)0
Rhettupcoming Test tours(03.01.2025, 13:36)(13:36)0
Mackenzie2023 West Indies vs England test match series(03.01.2025, 10:04)(10:04)0
Lanceindia bowled out cheaply(03.01.2025, 09:45)(09:45)0
GinoWest Indies vs England test match series 2023(03.01.2025, 07:32)(07:32)0
KaidenceJason Holder West Indies captaincy(03.01.2025, 06:43)(06:43)0
AllenWest Indies vs India first test(03.01.2025, 05:35)(05:35)0
MackenzieWest Indies vs England test match series 2023(03.01.2025, 05:24)(05:24)0
KendraWest Indies cricket upcoming Test series(03.01.2025, 03:57)(03:57)0
LayneWest Indies vs England test match series(02.01.2025, 16:26)(16:26)0
Milaniwomen's cricket(02.01.2025, 15:26)(15:26)0
Braxtonketchim(02.01.2025, 10:03)(10:03)0
ReedCARIVS 2020 contact(01.01.2025, 23:21)(23:21)0
CyrusBrian Lara Stadium inaugural match(01.01.2025, 23:17)(23:17)0
AlysonSuper User(01.01.2025, 18:58)(18:58)0
VeraWest Indies vs England test match series(01.01.2025, 17:52)(17:52)0
MilaniWest Indies vs Bangladesh cricket series(01.01.2025, 12:45)(12:45)0
Lancehappy new year(01.01.2025, 01:08)(01:08)0
ByronAustralia beat up on india(31.12.2024, 14:24)(14:24)0
JuliannaWest Indies vs England test match series(30.12.2024, 21:31)(21:31)0
KarlaSunil Philip Narine Test matches India(30.12.2024, 20:50)(20:50)0
MadilynnWest Indies vs England test match series(30.12.2024, 15:54)(15:54)0
EmersonIreland vs England Test cricket latest news(30.12.2024, 15:11)(15:11)0
JosieWest Indies vs Bangladesh(30.12.2024, 01:56)(01:56)0
ZainWest Indies cricket team latest Test match series performance(30.12.2024, 00:38)(00:38)0
TarynWest Indies vs New Zealand cricket match(29.12.2024, 22:47)(22:47)0
DemetriusWest Indies vs New Zealand upcoming cricket match discussion(29.12.2024, 14:15)(14:15)0
AryannaWest Indies vs Bangladesh series discussion(29.12.2024, 09:25)(09:25)0
Millie
Go to top