Perusing West Indies Keepers......the Best Man Shud Always be Pik

I am trying to figure out the best batting west indian keepers in order of class.....

looking at Ramdin and Dowrich today and the circumstances this interest came to mind..the best ever

the best batting keepers to my mind are :
1] Walcott
2] Dujon
3] Desmond Lewis

next..a bunch hard to separate

Ramdin
Jacobs
David Murray
Gerry Alexander
Ivor Mendonza

now Ramdn has scored 4-5 tons..more than Alexander and Jacobs who had 1 each.  I don't think David Murray had any.  but all these guys were strong batsmen who scored more often than not

then there was another bunch that cud also score led by
Jackie Hendriks
Deryck Murray
Derek Sealy
David Allan
Cyril Christiani
Ivan Barrow
Clairmonte Deeiaza

then there were the Brilliant keepers
Jackie Hendriks
Gerry Alexander
Simpson Guillen
David Murray
Dujon
Ramdin
Jacobs

en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_West_Indies_Test_wicket-keepers

You know I realised tha Art of Scouts

is not in the west indian set up any longer!

I am interested in the best team playing at all times..the best players.

it is a jackass thing, a self defeating thing... for Ramdin to be sitting while Dowrich is dropping catches behind the stumps and scoring nothing in front of them while west indies loose

and big men proposing a newbie Hamilton :

unbelieveable ! just cannot fathom that

how come you nah mention Ivan Madray ... :-\

Milton Pydana was overlooked despite being good. Deryck Murray was the chosen one during that period. 

I mention him earlier then removed the post on Milton with guyana police...

Madray and Pydana ....

Madray was not a keeper...

but Pydanna did get a game or 3 with the west indies at some point. it wasn't all in vain ::LOL:: ::LOL::

why you proposing the best players when than is not what our bajan selectors look at