Chanderpaul no longer good enough to play for West Indies - Holding

[quote author=Rowe992 link=topic=97764.msg639037#msg639037 date=1432988658]
Well I am sure that Chanderpaul was not the only West Indies batsman to struggle against England and there are a few still in the squad to face Australia. That Shay Hope guy looked very shaky and I don't expect any better against Australia. Brathwaite is also a hit or miss and therefore the struggle at the top of the order continues for the West Indies.
[/quote]
Brathwaite's numbers over the last calendar year have been very good: 53.52 average with 2 fifties and 4 centuries - though, admittedly, these numbers are boosted slightly by the 324 runs he scored against Bangladesh. Even if you take out the runs scored against Bangladesh, his average still stands at 41.86.

Just to add on to this, no opener has scored more runs or centuries over the last calendar year than Brathwaite.

half of his dismissals in England were to spin, and all bar one of the Anderson wickets were from lazy shots, not being beaten by pace or bounce.


I still think he’d have another 6 months in him. And even if he is on the down turn, they just don’t have the senior batsmen in and around the team to help with the transition. Who will they turn to for guidance and experience? The slew of T20 bandits?


The most mature person in the side now is Darren Bravo. And even he has a bucket load still to learn (although i rate him up there with Root and KW when it comes to technique and young temperament).

Whether anyone likes it or not Mikey always speaks his mind.

It was quite funny today when he was on and they showed him kicking the stumps down in NZ.

If Chanderpaul were saying that he deserves a place in the team, that would be one thing. WI have often been guilty of pensioning off their legends too early. Certainly Viv Richards should have played the '92 WC, Dessie Haynes deserved another year or two, and Brian Lara shouldn't have been pushed before the '07 Test tour of England.


But neither he nor his cohorts seem to be seriously disputing that he is past it as a batsman, and is no longer among the best six in the Caribbean. It's staggering that he feels entitled to a farewell Test series. Perhaps it's all the BCCI's fault for setting a precedent.

dude, India walk off deny the  great man 6 Innings of TEST cricket : that is the precedent you missing .

"feels entitled " ???...... get your facts straight !

BTW : Form is temporary , Class is permanent !

[quote author=Prince link=topic=97764.msg639520#msg639520 date=1433255762]
But neither he nor his cohorts seem to be seriously disputing that he is past it as a batsman, and is no longer among the best six in the Caribbean.
It's staggering that he feels entitled to a farewell Test series. Perhaps it's all the BCCI's fault for setting a precedent.
[/quote]

[quote author=ketchim link=topic=97764.msg639521#msg639521 date=1433255869]
dude, India walk off deny the  great man 6 Innings of TEST cricket : that is the precedent you missing . :

[/quote]

Correct is right .... and is quite possible that none of this controversy would've occurred had that Test series happened.  Oh well thanks to Bravo & co !! :-[ :-[ :-[

I tried to compose a calypso about the Walk OFF and director walk OUT :

but no one took me on the Trini Comess conspiracy for Lara record 

poster Prince is obviously a Trickie ... ::LOL::