SMITH REPLACES INJURED GAYLE IN SQUAD

WICB/Lloyd did not care about the test series...they just wanted to field a team.  Its the ODI and T20 they are focussed on. 

Dwayne Smith will be back in the Jungle for those games.

Dw Smith can be Windies Warner?

When? He has been playing for over 10 years now and he has not mustered it but let us assume you are right for the purposes of argument.

The issue here which you twist and turn away from are

You were arguing for Dwayne on the basis that Devon was playing in a losing team. Did you or did you not say that?

You have argued at great lengths that where a team finishes and the extent of losses is irrelevat! Did you or did you not argue this?

You did so why use that as an argument against Devon as his accumulated FC and current season is way ahead of Dwayne?

What form are you saying Dwayne has been better than Devon at? T20? Dwaye is no Warner!

I am sure you will twist and manipulate the above without answering them logically!

If you had said, like Mappippee, Matrix is the best of a very bad bunch then none of the above false statements come into play as they are baseless!

However the key point here is that Fudadin is an opener so the squad did not need a replacement opener, especially failures like the Smiths, so let him open with Brathwaite and seek an up and coming middle order batsman.

I will not respond to your girlish spiel above.

You just dont get it ** sigh**

Just the Facts :

Full name Dwayne Romel Smith
Current age 31 years 235 days
Major teams West Indies, Barbados, Barbados Tridents, West indies A
Chennai Super Kings, Deccan Chargers, Khulna Royal Bengals, Mumbai Indians, New South Wales, Sussex, Sylhet Royals


Full name Devon Sheldon Smith
Current age 33 years 43 days
Major teams West Indies, Southern Windward Islands, St Lucia Zouks, West Indies A, West Indies Under-19s, Windward Islands

Baby spoon feeding :  :-[

Full name David Andrew Warner
Current age 28 years 37 days
Major teams Australia, Australia A, Australia Under-19s,
Delhi Daredevils, Durham, Middlesex, New South Wales, Northern Districts, Sunrisers Hyderabad, Sydney Thunder

Ha ha ha....

So the best you can do is to copy and paste from Cricinfo?

Run but you cannot hide.

I will continue to pull you up on your biased inconsistent arguments.

Seems there is one rule for one set and variable one for others.

Be consistent, objective, impartial...

One time I threw a plastic bottle at Devon Smith, thinking he was Dwayne Smith. When I found out he was Devon Smith, I threw another bottle.

[quote author=Mail link=topic=94316.msg602425#msg602425 date=1417631339]
I will continue to pull you up on your biased inconsistent arguments.
[/quote]

You are out of your League !

You saw that as a cut and paste from cricInfo :

the rest of the Forum saw it as a highlight of International exposure !

Of David Warner and Dwayne Smith

** sigh ** 

[quote author=ketchim link=topic=94316.msg602428#msg602428 date=1417631862]
You are out of your League !
    (
[/quote]  True . You are in the minor league and he is in the major

Well anyone objective can see that you do not discuss and debate, you argue and have to be right.

You cannot accept when you are wrong as you are never wrong.

Ramesh has far more substance and integrity.

What arrogance ha ha ha!

ROTFL..... ;D ;D ;D ;D ;D ;D ;D ;D ;D ;D ;D