Lara, a cut above ...By Vaneisa Baksh

in this instance in use of stats I agree with the Rev.  I can see no way to defeat this one..no extenuating collection of contextual content that makes these figures moot...

3 batsmen at 50x/60x..that's domination  no doubt about it

Vanny Baksh is an impse as a writer. 

this is a long standing debate on west indian message boards.  she is shallow, usually threadbare and reaching... for gravitas.  that is how she reads and sounds.  I have defended her long time now for specific reasons.  these reasons do not apply here.

anyhow that journalistic challenge she accepted is unnecessarily restrictive rendering the project a sort of jackass one.

why limit the number to 5.  that does not seem right. there are more to be considered.  you have to find the outstanding number of great batsmen over the time..and what is the time frame under review here..and  pick the corresponding number of writers to try to do justice to the issue.

I mean right away I could see Viv Richards must be included..maybe David Gower, Graham Gooch, Ian Chappelle etc

they have to define the term 'modern' batsman

[quote author=TRINIDADDY link=topic=86737.msg543149#msg543149 date=1389312559]
[size=12pt]


"The reason Brian Lara stands head and shoulder above Tendulkar, Ponting, Kallis and Dravid is because he was more dominant than all of them."


[/size]
[/quote]


* The Rev provided mathematical evidence of Lara's DOMINANCE.

* [size=14pt]Only 3 batsmen in history have averaged 50+ with the bat along with a 60+ STRIKE RATE---Richards, Lara and Hayden.[/size]

* Baksh and others were comparing 5 batsmen---Tendulkar, Ponting, Kallis, Dravid and Lara.

* Lara averaged 50+ with a 60+ strike rate----the others did not.

* Therefore Lara stands at the head of the pack.

Rev

[quote author=mapoui link=topic=86737.msg543178#msg543178 date=1389358552]
[size=14pt]in this instance in use of stats I agree with the Rev.  I can see no way to defeat this one..no extenuating collection of contextual content that makes these figures moot...[/size]

3 batsmen at 50x/60x..that's domination  no doubt about it

Vanny Baksh is an impse as a writer. 

[/quote]

[size=18pt]The above post was Mapoui's best ever on any cricket message board.[/size]

Rev

am gettin bettah wit' age! :-[ :-[ :-[

kudos to both Trinidaddy and mapoui  !

For accepting how Dominance really is measured 

Calypso , I was being civil but yeah , she is a long winded journo ..

if vanessa understood stats, she would have used them.  She is just using emotions. 

why not?  RBK is the greatest in my book....and I know certain "president" who believes the same! And RBK did not even average 50!

But when he walks to the wicket to bat on any ground around the world, it was the most electrifying moment!  No other batsman in the world created such an effect on the crowd!! NONE!

Ponting is a reformed drunk .... :-[

Kallis had Hair transplant ...

[quote author=ketchim link=topic=86737.msg543228#msg543228 date=1389372048]
Ponting is a reformed drunk .... :-[
[/quote]

why you think de man loves to play in the caribbean so much.?  is sheer rum flowing!  8)