Should Chanders and Sarwan be on the ODI team?

Should Chanders and Sarwan be on the WI ODI team, or do we stick with young players are rebuild?

I mean, I honestly think Chanders will give you 60 to 100 runs at a 70-120 strike rate every game. What's wrong with that?

Sarwan has more chinks in his armour, but Charles, Powel and the young-guns not making any waves.

Batting-wise, only the Bravos and Ramdin seem to be improving.

WICB said they too lazy


so don't look for them in WICB ODI team

Perhaps Shiv but Sarwan is yet to prove his suitability. Good start to the 50 overs competition but missing the Jamaica game was idiotic. A big 50 against them would have meant more that against Ireland or even WI.


WhoEver is not constantly playing their strongest team should be sot...metaphorically.

Do we know why Sars missed the Jamaica game?

ketch said flu. lets see if we can verify that

Ramnaresh Sarwan missed the Jamaican game because he was infected with the flu.  I do believe both of them should be on the West Indies ODI team.  Sarwan has showed good form so far in this tournament, while Chanderpaul has displayed his value as an ODI opening batsman.  Let us not forget that his ODI record as a opening batsman with Chris Gayle has been the best in the last 10 years. 

Shiv definitely ....... His non-selection defies common sense on the part of the selectors/coach  :-[

Sarwan .. Yes ... IF he is in the 4 or 5 top scoring batsmen of the tournament, then he has earned a come back !!!

Who are the top runs scorers anyways in this tourney so far?

[quote author=Calypso link=topic=87565.msg548776#msg548776 date=1392121996]

Who are the top runs scorers anyways in this tourney so far?
[/quote]

Sarwan  with 151....even though he miss a Match with the flu  8)

most 4s and most 6s....as well

Shiv is Third with 144 , even though he missed a match to give Fuda a knock ..

http://stats.espncricinfo.com/ci/engine/...tournament

Numbers 1 and 3 in MOST runs scored :

despite both missing a Match  !

WoW !  8)