Your continued points about Shakib is one of the reasons I asked the question, more to create discussion as it is obvious what is a good average or not and you know those players who do not have a great average but actually win games.
Forgetting the official rankings what would be everyone's top 10?
Say someone like Samuels who has abysmal numbers, do you consider him in the same light of a Shakib for example?
[/quote]
Yeah, I'm not saying that stats are meaningless, but just that too much emphasis shouldn't be put on stats especially in ODIs.
Samuels is one of the cases where his average perfectly reflects how well he's been doing.
Top 10 as in purely batting or should other aspects - i.e. fielding and bowling be taken into teh equation too?