+- Cricket Windies (https://cricketwindies.com)
+-- Forum: What’s on Your Mind? (https://cricketwindies.com/forum-3.html)
+--- Forum: The Water Cooler! (https://cricketwindies.com/forum-4.html)
+--- Thread: After Paris, let’s stop blaming Muslims and take a hard look at ourselves (/thread-28196.html)
Pages:
1
2
After Paris, let’s stop blaming Muslims and take a hard look at ourselves - Chin - 11-19-2015
Our terrorism double standard: After Paris, let’s stop blaming Muslims and take a hard look at ourselves
Any time there is an attack on civilians in the post-9/11 West, demagogues immediately blame it on Muslims. They frequently lack evidence, but depend on the blunt force of anti-Muslim bigotry to bolster their accusations.
Actual evidence, on the other hand, shows that less than two percent of terrorist attacks from 2009 to 2013 in the E.U. were religiously motivated. In 2013, just one percent of the 152 terrorist attacks were religious in nature; in 2012, less than three percent of the 219 terrorist attacks were inspired by religion.
The vast majority of terrorist attacks in these years were motivated by ethno-nationalism or separatism. In 2013, 55 percent of terrorist attacks were ethno-nationalist or separatist in nature; in 2012, more than three-quarters (76 percent) of terrorist attacks were inspired by ethno-nationalism or separatism.
These facts, nonetheless, have never stopped the prejudiced pundits from insisting otherwise.
As soon as the news of the attacks broke, even though there was no evidence and practically nothing was known about the attackers, a Who’s Who of right-wing pundits immediately latched on to the violence as an opportunity to demonize Muslims and refugees from Muslim-majority countries.
More insidiously, when evidence began to suggest that extremists were responsible for the attacks, and when ISIS eventually claimed responsibility, the demagogues implied or even downright insisted that Islam — the religion of 1.6 billion people — was to blame, and that the predominately (although not entirely) Muslim refugees entering the West are only going to carry out more of such attacks.
Clampdown on Muslims and refugees
Two primary groups: One, Islamic extremist groups themselves, who use the clampdown as “evidence†that there is supposedly no room for Muslims in the secular West that has declared war on Islam; and two, Europe’s growing far-right, who will use the attacks as “evidence†that there is supposedly no room for Muslims in the secular West that should declare war on Islam.
More specifically, to name names, ISIS and al-Qaeda will benefit from the clampdown on Muslims and refugees, and Europe’s growing far-right movement will continue to recruit new members with anti-Muslim and anti-refugee propaganda.
Western culpability
The West frequently acts as though it is the principal victim, but the exact contrary is true.
Never interrogated is why exactly are so many refugees fleeing the Middle East and North Africa. It is not like millions of people want to leave their homes and families; they are fleeing violence and chaos — violence and chaos that happens to almost always be the result of Western military intervention.
Western countries, particularly the U.S., are directly responsible for the violence and destruction in Iraq, Afghanistan, Libya, and Yemen, from which millions of refugees are fleeing:
The illegal U.S.-led invasion of Iraq led to the deaths of at least one million people, destabilized the entire region, and created extreme conditions in which militant groups like al-Qaeda spread like wildfire, eventually leading to the emergence of ISIS.
In Afghanistan, the ongoing U.S.-led war and occupation — which the Obama administration just prolonged for a second time — has led to approximately a quarter of a million deaths and has displaced millions of Afghans.
The disastrous U.S.-led NATO intervention in Libya destroyed the government, turning the country into a hotbed for extremism and allowing militant groups like ISIS to spread west into North Africa. Thousands of Libyans have been killed, and hundreds of thousands made refugees.
In Yemen, the U.S. and other Western nations are arming and backing the Saudi-led coalition that is raining down bombs, including banned cluster munitions, on civilian areas, pulverizing the poorest country in the Middle East. And, once again — the story should now be familiar — thousands have been killed and hundreds of thousands have been displaced.
Syria is a bit more complicated. Many refugees in the country, which has been torn apart by almost five years of bitter war, are fleeing the brutal repression of the Assad government. Western countries and their allies, however, share some of the blame. Allies such as Saudi Arabia and Turkey have greatly inflamed the conflict by supporting extremist groups like al-Qaeda affiliate al-Nusra.
And it should go without saying that millions of Syrian refugees are fleeing the very same terror at the hands of ISIS that the group allegedly unleashed upon Paris. By suppressing Syrian and Iraqi refugees fleeing the ruthlessly violent extremist group, France and other Western countries will only be further adding to the already shocking number of its victims.
Dislocating the blame
When the U.S. and its allies bomb weddings and hospitals in Yemen and Afghanistan, killing hundreds of civilians, “Americans†doesn’t trend globally on Twitter. Yet when Parisians are allegedly killed by Islamic extremists, “Muslims†does.
The imperialist West always try to dislocate the blame. It’s always the foreigner’s, the non-Westerner’s, the Other’s fault; it’s never the fault of the enlightened West.
Unfortunately, tragedies like the one we see in Paris are daily events in much of the Middle East, no thanks to the policies of the governments of France, the U.S., the U.K., and more. The horrific and unjustifiable yet rare terrorist attacks we in the West experience are the quotidian reality endured by those living in the region our governments brutalize.
This does not mean we should not mourn the Paris attacks; they are abominable, and the victims should and must be mourned. But we should likewise ensure that the victims of our governments’ crimes are mourned as well.
If we truly believe that all lives are equally valuable, if we truly believe that French lives matter no more than any others, we must mourn all deaths equally.
Moreover, Western countries’ propping up of their oil-rich allies in the Gulf, extremist theocratic monarchies like Saudi Arabia, is a principal factor in the spread of Sunni extremism. The Obama administration did more than $100 billion of arms deals with the Saudi monarchy in the past five years, and France has increasingly signed enormous military contracts with theocratic autocracies like Saudi Arabia, the UAE, and Qatar.
If these are the strategies our governments continue to pursue, attacks like those in Paris will only be more frequent.
The pundits will boost anti-Muslim bigotry and feed the anti-refugee fervor. In doing so, they will only make matters worse.
The Paris attacks, as horrific as they are, could be a moment to think critically about what our governments are doing both abroad and here at home. If we do not think critically, if we act capriciously, and violently, the wounds will only continue to fester. The bloodletting will ultimately accelerate.
In short, those who promote militarist policies and anti-Muslim and anti-refugee bigotries in response to the Paris attacks are only going to further propagate violence and hatred.
If the political cycle is not changed, the cycle of violence will continue.
Re: After Paris, let’s stop blaming Muslims and take a hard look at ourselves - ketchim - 11-20-2015
Nope ....its too much of an effort !
the path of least resistance is to blame others .
Re: After Paris, let’s stop blaming Muslims and take a hard look at ourselves - SCA - 11-20-2015
[quote author=Chin link=topic=101483.msg664981#msg664981 date=1448029914]
Can we be critique ourself ? ::confused::
[/quote]
Chin, haven't you been doing that? Hasn't the media, and fringe publications, all critiqued the west? The conspiracy theorists, those who revel in the demise of the west, the psychos...aren't they all voicing their opinions. Some go the extra yard to fabricate facts.
Now lets see....where does responsibility really lie? Who critique the critics?
Re: After Paris, let’s stop blaming Muslims and take a hard look at ourselves - ketchim - 11-20-2015
Chin , u gotta break that down further for this forum "level"
even suggesting leaving the people place including Guantanamo. Cuba
would need a further breaking down ....
doan even mention : O-I-L
Re: After Paris, let’s stop blaming Muslims and take a hard look at ourselves - SCA - 11-20-2015
[quote author=Chin link=topic=101483.msg665010#msg665010 date=1448032012]
If we truly want to end the abominable acts of violence perpetrated by extremist groups like ISIS and al-Qaida, we should take to heart the simple yet profound counsel of Noam Chomsky, another modern-day Cassandra: “Everybody’s worried about stopping terrorism. Well, there’s a really easy way: stop participating in it.â€
SCA ..the highlighted says it all....
[/quote]
Chin, quickly. Where do you live? And why? Perhaps you could have selected a better place than the west. But I am sure that you are much smarter than that.
You really believe that those folks are rational???? Do you understand that these people are highly unsophisticated, highly uneducated, and very emotional. The have no respect for life. Whereas ISIS and Al Qaida are of the modern era, their philosophy is not new. They are here to fight the religious war. Religious extremism has always been a hallmark of that region of the world. As far as I know, the US and the west do not target innocent people. They have bombing campaign directed at the intended targets.
These psychos target innocent people...shooting defenseless, men women and children, all in the name of god. Sick? Your call.
I will gladly live in the west every time, all the time, than live in a world of crazies. So I see it. And I am sure so do you.
Re: After Paris, let’s stop blaming Muslims and take a hard look at ourselves - ketchim - 11-20-2015
[quote author=SCA link=topic=101483.msg665018#msg665018 date=1448033861]
As far as I know, the US and the west do not target innocent people.
[/quote]
Kindergarten level plagues this Forum :
Re: After Paris, let’s stop blaming Muslims and take a hard look at ourselves - SCA - 11-20-2015
http://nypost.com/2015/11/20/gunmen-attack-mali-hotel-americans-told-to-take-shelter/
Another day in paradise!
Re: After Paris, let’s stop blaming Muslims and take a hard look at ourselves - ketchim - 11-20-2015
SCA ha u on Ignore ::LOL:: ::LOL::
Re: After Paris, let’s stop blaming Muslims and take a hard look at ourselves - SCA - 11-20-2015
Chin...your stats are impressive....just remember to give source credit.
I did not agree with the Iraqi invasion. I do not agree with the US foreign policy. But that doesn't make me less patriotic to this country. And I there is harm done to this country and its interest overseas, then it impacts me directly of indirectly.
Now a war, however misguided the Iraq war was, has fatalities as a direct consequence. It is regrettable that many lost their lives. War is ugly.
Remember the Arab spring? Weren't the folks overjoyed about the new freedom? The people, perhaps goaded by the west, were reveling in change.
Re: After Paris, let’s stop blaming Muslims and take a hard look at ourselves - SCA - 11-20-2015
[quote author=Chin link=topic=101483.msg665133#msg665133 date=1448050829]
Chin...your stats are impressive....just remember to give source credit.
I did ..note I used IBC stats ...
You American's killed thousands of innocent people ...its factual .
Now you wonder why the genie is about to bite your arse...and now America is claiming to be so innocent ..
I have a misty eye , for America... :'( :'(
[/quote]
Where is America claiming to be innocent? Who said that?
Where are the thousands of the innocents that the Americans killed? How do you conveniently forget to mention the stats of the ISIS al Qaida, internal wars, regional conflicts? Know they enemy.