+- Cricket Windies (https://cricketwindies.com)
+-- Forum: What’s on Your Mind? (https://cricketwindies.com/forum-3.html)
+--- Forum: The Water Cooler! (https://cricketwindies.com/forum-4.html)
+--- Thread: Justify killing animals for food ! (/thread-27685.html)
Pages:
1
2
Justify killing animals for food ! - ketchim - 10-30-2015
You could say that if you kill a cow you're depriving it of the rest of its existence, which could also have been a happy,
good existence, so why deprive it of that just because you want to eat some meat
when you've got other healthy, nutritious, delicious things that you could also eat ?
Re: Justify killing animals for food ! - ketchim - 10-30-2015
The counter-argument is this cow would not have existed if we had not already planned in advance that at some point
we would kill it and we would sell the meat, because obviously it costs something to rear a cow,
and we can only meet that cost if we are going to kill it.
Re: Justify killing animals for food ! - ketchim - 10-30-2015
If a cow is killed that will make it possible for another cow to come into existence who will have a good life
and if the first cow were not killed it would not be possible for the other cow to come into existence.
Re: Justify killing animals for food ! - ketchim - 10-30-2015
So yes, this cow standing in front of us will lose the rest of her life, but that loss is replaced by bringing the other cow
into existence and the other cow will also have that happy life.
Re: Justify killing animals for food ! - Meseret - 10-30-2015
Kill the excess bulls and save the heifers ...
All the bulls do is have sex, no?
Re: Justify killing animals for food ! - ketchim - 10-30-2015
Meseret LoL
: I do not unnastan the Karma and Dharma of the Cow .In a sense the cow could thank us for his/her existence - at least he/she has some existence rather than none !!
So I will ask for some knowledgeable explanation by my Hindu brothers and sisters 8)
Re: Justify killing animals for food ! - ketchim - 10-30-2015
waiting on the learned Pandi Goog Lee
OR the not so learned Kwami.
OR the "I" and "Me" ....SCA
Re: Justify killing animals for food ! - mapoui - 10-31-2015
as far as I see the only morality in life is that which is dictated by survival. it so happens that general survival requires that humanity live in consistency with the truth we prove about nature as we go.
we are carnivores and would not be here but eating meat. and remember we got eaten as well..unless when we ded we get bun. if not at some point we will be eaten for sure..even if it is unlikely any more for us to get get creamed by lion, tiger or some big cat..a shark or a crawling 'Macawell' or some such monster
we never used to ask these questions about meat. these questions come purely from modern, comfortable life and the moralities associated with the religions. maybe we eat too much meat...and that may be a moral question. eating meat may not be.
but if the animals can turn this thing around guess who will be on their tables, all dressed up and seasoned, cherry in mouth and trussed-up in 'roast fowl' position....like a padnah ah mine deh used to call 'Roast' because deh walked in on his girl friend in a an awful roast fowl with a man who was not he.
pheeeeeeeeee! allyuh think it sorf! :
: : : : : : : : : : :anyhow just now we have have transporter technology to make replicators so we can order up meats from the replicator straight up without have to slaughter anything.
wouldn't that be nice. I could order up by Chinese BBQ duck with no fear...for some of which I fee for right now
::LOL:: ::LOL:: ::LOL:: ::LOL:: ::LOL::
Re: Justify killing animals for food ! - Kwami - 11-01-2015
[quote author=ketchim link=topic=100936.msg661595#msg661595 date=1446226798]
OR the not so learned Kwami.
[/quote] ?????
Re: Justify killing animals for food ! - ketchim - 11-01-2015
Goog Lee seh he is the only one "learned" to answer the Cow question
