+- Cricket Windies (https://cricketwindies.com)
+-- Forum: Rally Around West Indies! (https://cricketwindies.com/forum-1.html)
+--- Forum: We don't like cricket. We love it. (https://cricketwindies.com/forum-2.html)
+--- Thread: ICC accepts umpiring error on Anderson run-out (/thread-23104.html)
Re: ICC accepts umpiring error on Anderson run-out - Calypso - 02-14-2015
[quote author=midwicket link=topic=95819.msg618705#msg618705 date=1423939457]
why does australia like to cheat
[/quote]
Huh? .... more like England (Well to be precise James Taylor) robbed by the Umpires. Why didn't the Umpires and Match Referee know the rules and speak up? This is real embarrassment for the ICC ... reminds me of the fiasco of the 2007 WC
Re: ICC accepts umpiring error on Anderson run-out - DownUnda - 02-14-2015
"Article 3.6a of Appendix 6 of the Decision Review System Playing Conditions states that the ball should have been deemed dead when the batsman (James Taylor) was given out LBW. No further runs or dismissals were possible.
Why were they running if they knew it was a dead ball?!?!?!
Re: ICC accepts umpiring error on Anderson run-out - ketchim - 02-14-2015
was he out LBW ?
Re: ICC accepts umpiring error on Anderson run-out - Calypso - 02-14-2015
[quote author=ketchim link=topic=95819.msg618776#msg618776 date=1423959568]
he sure did : I feel bad for him and Jimmeh !
[/quote]
Me too Ketch
Some people are saying that this match should be nullified or each team awarded a point as it didn't end properly !!!
Re: ICC accepts umpiring error on Anderson run-out - DownUnda - 02-14-2015
Nullified Cal? That's a lil absurd dontcha think
Re: ICC accepts umpiring error on Anderson run-out - Calypso - 02-14-2015
[quote author=ketchim link=topic=95819.msg618781#msg618781 date=1423960225]
was he out LBW ?
[/quote]
He was struck on the pad by Josh Hazlewood and given lbw by umpire Aleem Dar. Taylor and James Anderson took off for a leg bye while the umpire was deliberating. Dar raised his finger while the batsmen were running. Then Glenn Maxwell's throw hit the stumps at the non-striker's end with Anderson short of his ground.
Taylor asked for a review of the lbw. It was found to be missing leg, and he was reprieved. Australia asked the umpires about the run-out of Anderson. Taylor argued the point, saying a dead ball should be called. The umpires discussed it, square-leg umpire Kumar Dharmasena appeared to speak to someone on his radio, and it was decided that the run-out could be checked and given out.
Now they say they made an error according to the rules ...
Re: ICC accepts umpiring error on Anderson run-out - Calypso - 02-14-2015
[quote author=DownUnda link=topic=95819.msg618785#msg618785 date=1423960518]
Nullified Cal? That's a lil absurd dontcha think
[/quote]
Maybe .... and the situation will most likely be left as is which is an awful way to start a WC :-[
Re: ICC accepts umpiring error on Anderson run-out - DownUnda - 02-14-2015
Surely de ICC coulda darn well do better than Dar & Dharamsena, they always seem inept & clueless
Re: ICC accepts umpiring error on Anderson run-out - ketchim - 02-14-2015
who was the 3rd Ump that ruled the run out as legal ?
Re: ICC accepts umpiring error on Anderson run-out - Calypso - 02-14-2015
[quote author=ketchim link=topic=95819.msg618795#msg618795 date=1423962135]
who was the 3rd Ump that ruled the run out as legal ?
[/quote]
The match referee here was Jeff Crowe, the on-field umpires Dharmasena and Dar, the third umpire Billy Bowden and the fourth umpire Joel Wilson. Did none of them know the playing conditions and speak up? It is notable that Crowe was also the match referee in the 2007 World Cup final, Dar was one of the on-field umpires and Bowden the fourth umpire. :-[